When a repair shop questions your auto protection plan or extended car warranty, it’s usually because of confusion about the process or contract details—not because the company doesn’t want to pay. Common issues include disagreements over labor costs or timelines, paperwork requirements, the scope of coverage, and getting proper approvals.

To make the process smoother, always read your contract carefully, save written records, and contact Endurance before agreeing to any extra repairs. Read on to learn more about what you can do when your repair shop is challenging your warranty claim.

Why Repair Shop Disputes Happen

Taking your car to a mechanic can be stressful: you’re left without a vehicle, and you have to plan for alternative transportation. But receiving news that your warranty claim is being denied by the mechanic only makes the situation worse. Of course, your knee-jerk reaction is anger and confusion. You’ve already invested in Endurance or another third-party extended warranty or vehicle service contract (VSC). How can you possibly be responsible for the repair bill?

There are several reasons you might find yourself in this scenario, and most stem from differences in labor rates, documentation requirements, and unexpected extra damage. Taking the time to understand the claims process and identifying the covered components and exclusions listed in your extended car warranty can help prevent future frustrations and unplanned repair costs. Consider a few of the most common disputes you might face from the repair shop after filing an automotive repair claim, and what steps you can take to avoid these hassles.

“We Don’t Work With Warranty Companies”

When a repair facility works with providers like Endurance Warranty Services, it means the shop is familiar with the claims process and agrees to follow the contract’s payment guidelines. Many reputable shops employ ASE-certified technicians, though certification requirements vary by facility.

To avoid issues with out-of-network mechanics, confirm which repair shops are authorized by your warranty provider before you need service. If you missed this step or thought your mechanic was in-network but they aren’t, review the warranty terms and choose a repair shop or dealership that your provider works with. This can help reduce delays and support smoother processing of covered repairs.

“That Part Isn’t Covered”

It’s no secret that standard gas-powered cars are complex machines with thousands of parts. So when a component breaks down, it may require repairs to multiple parts to get it back up and running. However, not all auto warranty coverage is created equally. In fact, many contracts exclude wear-and-tear items and a long list of other components. Unfortunately, not everyone who invests in an extended car warranty reads the agreement’s fine print and understands what it covers and what it limits.

If a mechanical breakdown occurs and a non-covered part fails alongside a covered component, you will likely be responsible for the cost of the non-covered part on your used car. That said, as the paying customer, you have the right to question or challenge a repair and to seek a second opinion on an auto repair estimate. Still, your vehicle service contract provider, such as Endurance, can clarify coverage limits, recommended repairs, and whether your contract covers a specific part.

“The Labor Time or Rate Isn’t Enough”

Not all repairs are quick and easy. While some are as simple as replacing a wiper blade or light bulb, many are complex and time-consuming. With advances in technology and specialized parts, labor times and rates can exceed what is specified in the contract. Unfortunately, this can lead to friction between repair shops and customers, especially when a customer uses a mechanic who is not ASE-certified or authorized by their warranty provider.

In simpler terms, if a shop charges labor rates above what your contract allows, the provider may only approve payment up to the contract limits, and you could be responsible for any difference. Labor guides provide a baseline for the estimated time a repair should take, helping establish a fair cost. As the customer, you can either pay the difference, negotiate with the repair shop, initiate a dispute with your warranty provider, or get quotes from other auto shops that accept your warranty’s rates.

“We Need Payment Before Teardown”

Obtaining authorization from your warranty provider is a critical step in the claim approval process. Before your mechanic starts taking things apart, your contract may require confirmation of a part failure first. If your mechanic requires payment in advance, contact your provider as soon as possible to either authorize the repair, clarify coverage, or have the repair facility submit the claim.

“We Can’t Start Until Approval”

In any situation, no repair work should start before your provider authorizes your claim. Starting repairs before authorization can lead to denied claims or unexpected out-of-pocket costs under the terms of your contract. To prevent a claim denial, always get your provider’s approval first.

What to Do If a Shop Challenges a Claim

While there are several reasons a shop may not honor your extended car warranty or dispute its coverage, there are steps you can take to help de-escalate the situation and address it. To start, request written documentation for the challenged warranty claim.

On your end, keep records of all conversations you have with the shop, including dates and receipts. This way, you can provide your warranty provider with proof of the shop’s issues and any work that has been completed or not. Also, thoroughly review your VSC or extended car warranty to understand the terms and whether you have leverage against the auto shop’s challenges.

Finally, contact Endurance or your third-party provider before approving any additional work. The last thing you want to do is risk claim complications by failing to follow the contract’s requirements.

How to Keep the Repair Moving

The best way to ensure your car’s repairs aren’t halted is to communicate proactively with your mechanic and warranty provider. Be sure to avoid unauthorized repairs, which can cause additional delays, and follow up with the repair shop and provider as needed. And when it’s time to pay your deductible, be prepared to pay it. At times, you may need to push for approvals and parts, especially as rental car services near their end. For peace of mind, don’t be afraid to ask questions or for a timeline so you know what to expect.

Who to Contact When You Need Help

If you’re still unsure how to appeal a warranty denial, our experienced team is here to help. Remember, if something isn’t clear, ask! We’re always available to support you.

If you’ve just started shopping for an Endurance Warranty plan, feel free to browse our convenient online store for price and plan recommendations and explore our Endurance Warranty reviews to see what our satisfied customers are saying. You can also contact an Endurance representative at (800) 253-8203 or request your FREE email quote today.

Read more about Endurance and other extended warranty companies on our blog.