Choosing the most reliable midsize SUV or compact SUV, perhaps one with all-wheel drive or FWD, can play an important role in your overall ownership experience. While a used SUV or crossover can provide excellent horsepower, better fuel economy and fuel efficiency, and top-notch legroom, it can also be a source of stress if you find yourself worrying about repairs all the time. The last thing you want to deal with is a vehicle that is constantly in the shop, and both the Ford Edge and the Chevrolet Equinox are commonly considered dependable options.

Both of these used SUVs have above-average reliability scores from RepairPal, with each one coming in at 3.5 out of 5 stars. They also both have quality infotainment systems, great towing capacity, and plenty of cubic feet for cargo space. When it comes to their individual issues, though, they are very different SUVs. The Edge is larger and slightly more expensive to maintain, while the Equinox tends to have more severe issues when they come up. This may make the Equinox a suitable option for some drivers, particularly when considering additional protection.

Knowing the specifics of these vehicles and how they stack up will help you make the right choice when the time comes.

Ford Edge Reliability

​The Ford Edge has a RepairPal reliability rating of 3.5 out of 5, making it an excellent option if you’re looking to reduce the likelihood of frequent major repairs. It has an average yearly cost of ownership of $611, placing it generally in line with others in its category. It does, however, have some concerning areas that you should be on the lookout for if you own one of these SUVs.

Certain model years of this crossover SUV were associated with faulty airbags, which resulted in a recall, and there have been several complaints of fuel tank leaks and other flaws, which may present safety concerns if not addressed. Before you purchase a used Edge, be sure to check for recalls relating to the specific model year to make sure everything is in order.​

Chevrolet Equinox Reliability

​The Chevy Equinox has the same reliability rating as the Ford Edge, but it also has a few added benefits. Perhaps the biggest one is a lower annual maintenance cost of $537 and fewer average visits to a repair shop, which may appeal to drivers prioritizing lower routine maintenance costs. The downside of the Equinox, though, is that when it has to go to the shop, it may involve more significant repairs when issues arise. Eighteen percent (18%) of the Equinox’s shop visits are for major repairs.

Transmission faults, rough shifting, or check engine lights tied to powertrain sensors have been reported in certain model years of the Equinox, especially in the older generations. These repairs can vary in cost and may be significant in some cases, so it is a good idea to have a protection plan in place so you can get the help you need when they come up.

Common Repair Issues Side-by-Side

​Ownership Costs Side-by-Side

​What This Means for Used Buyers in 2026

​Choosing between these two SUVs will depend heavily on what you are looking for in a vehicle. If, for example, you are looking for the most budget-friendly option in the short term, the Chevy Equinox may be your best bet. With its fairly low average annual cost, you’ll have lower routine maintenance costs to keep it on the road.

When it comes to repairs, though, it may require more extensive repairs in some cases when something goes wrong. If you are willing to either take that gamble or take steps to make sure you are covered in the event of a major breakdown, you could end up saving a lot of money over the years.

​For those who need an SUV that is built on a larger platform to allow for more headroom, more space in the rear seat, and a longer wheelbase, the Ford Edge, especially in its AWD configuration, is a great choice. On top of that, it may also be less likely to need major repairs.

When it comes to annual costs, though, it is slightly more expensive, and it has a lower MPG rating due to its larger size. Balancing these costs will help you make the right choice for yourself, your family, and your bank account.

Extended Warranty vs. Paying Out of Pocket

​If you are considering either of these SUV options for your next used vehicle purchase, it is important to be as prepared as possible. When large repairs come up, you can find yourself faced with a bill for thousands of dollars, depending on the issue. And if you don’t have the emergency fund to cover it, a major repair can create financial strain on your budget.

With both of these vehicles, there is the possibility of dealing with large, expensive repairs. The Equinox, though, is associated with higher-cost repairs in some cases, so it can be helpful to plan ahead for when the time comes.

​If your SUV needs a large repair, you can either pay out of pocket or have an extended car warranty in place. An extended warranty, which is more accurately called a vehicle service contract (VSC), can be purchased from a third-party provider like Endurance and comes with all kinds of benefits.

Paying out of pocket can be a good solution if you are sure you will have the ability to pay the bill, but most people are not willing or able to pay for a $2,000 transmission replacement if one comes up. While you’ll have to pay a monthly premium to keep your coverage active, it can end up being well worth it in the end if you end up dealing with a major repair down the line.

Final Recommendation: Chevrolet Equinox

​Both the Ford Edge and the Chevy Equinox are great options for people who want a comfortable, dependable vehicle for the whole family—and are both worth the test drive. While the Edge has fewer major issues, its higher annual costs affect its affordability in the short term. The Chevy Equinox is the stronger option, coupled with a vehicle protection plan that can help cover repairs down the line.

Auto Protection Plans for Your Ford or Chevy

When you want to protect your vehicle and keep everything running smoothly, Endurance has a plan that is just right for you. Whether you have an older high-mileage vehicle or an exotic luxury car, there is an Endurance plan designed to protect it. Endurance also has options for vehicles that other providers won’t cover, such as Canadian Gray Market cars, vehicles with a rebuilt or salvage title, and cars used for commercial purposes like rideshare or delivery.

In addition to coverage options, Endurance also offers a wide range of extra benefits to all customers. These include things like 24/7 roadside assistance, travel interruption protection, and rental car reimbursement. Plus, you can access a year of Endurance’s Elite Benefits, which come with tire repair or replacement, key fob replacement, windshield coverage, and more.*

To explore coverage options for your vehicle, get in touch with our team at (800) 253-8203 for a FREE quote. You can also shop online to see your price right away and make the right choice.

For more auto expert resources like this one, be sure to check out the Endurance Warranty blog. There, you will find DIY tips, comparisons of different VSC providers, and much more.